banner

Board of Education Regular Meeting
West Contra Costa USD
January 18, 2017 6:30PM
LOVONYA DEJEAN MIDDLE SCHOOL 3400 MACDONALD AVENUE RICHMOND, CA 94805

A. CLOSED SESSION
A.1. CALL TO ORDER
A.2. DISCLOSURE OF ITEMS TO BE DISCUSSED IN CLOSED SESSION - (Government Code 54957.7)
A.3. RECESS TO CLOSED SESSION AS SCHEDULED
Quick Summary / Abstract:

The Board will convene at 6:00 PM in the Multi-Purpose Room to receive comments from anyone wishing to address the Board regarding closed session items.  The Board will then adjourn to closed session and reconvene in open session to address the regular agenda at 6:30 PM.



A.3.1. CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL-ANTICIPATED LITIGATION/SIGNIFICANT EXPOSURE TO LITIGATION [Government Code Section 54956.9(d)(2) or (d)(3)]
Quick Summary / Abstract:

Six cases

A.3.2. CONFERENCE WITH LABOR NEGOTIATORS
Quick Summary / Abstract:

WCCUSD Negotiators: Superintendent Matthew Duffy and Assistant Superintendent Ken Whittemore for the following groups:
  a.    Employee Organizations
         -UTR
         -Local One
         -School Supervisors Association
         -WCCAA
 b.     Unrepresented Employees
         -Confidential and Management

A.3.3. REPORT OF CLOSED SESSION ACTIONS
B. OPENING PROCEDURES
Minutes:
President Block called the meeting to order at 6:00 P.M. The Board recessed into Closed Session. President Block called the Public Session to order at 6: 37 P.M.
B.1. Pledge of Allegiance
Minutes:
President Block led the Pledge of Allegiance.
B.2. Welcome and Meeting Procedures
Minutes:
President Block offered welcome and instructions to the public regarding the meeting.
B.3. Roll Call
Minutes:
Board Members Present: Liz Block, Madeline Kronenberg, Tom Panas, Mister Phillips, Student Representative Angel Jones
Staff Present: Carol Butcher, Executive Director; Elizabeth Carmody, Director; Denise Cifelli, Sr. Confidential Secretary; Steve Collins, Interim Assistant Superintendent Special Education, Patricia Cuevas, Translator; Matthew Duffy, Superintendent; Luis Freese, District Engineer; Sheri Gamba, Associate Superintendent Business Services; Joshua Herrera, Maintenance Supervisor; Nicole Joyner, Director Assessment; Lisa LeBlanc, Associate Superintendent M & O/Bond Program; Vincent Meyers, Executive Director, M & O; Mary Phillips, Chief Technology Officer; Nia Rashidchi, Interim Associate Superintendent PreK-Adult Educational Operations; Marin Trujillo, Coordinator Community Engagement; Marcus Walton, Communications Director; Ken Whittemore, Assistant Superintendent Human Resources
B.4. Report/Ratification of Closed Session
Minutes:
None
B.5. Recognize Participation of Student Board Representatives
Speaker:
Matthew Duffy, Superintendent
Comments:

Two students from the Youth Commission have served as Student Representatives to the Board of Education for the first semester of 2016-2017.  The Board would like to recognize and commend Angel Jones from Kennedy High School and Dominick Ojeda from Pinole Valley High School for their participation.  They have contributed the student perspective on behalf of the Youth Commission and their peers in an articulate and engaging manner.  The Board will express appreciation.

Financial Impact:

None

Minutes:
President Block noted that Student Representative Dominque Ojeda was unable to attend but fortunate enough to be in Washington D.C. attending the inauguration. Superintendent Duffy recognized Student Representative Angel Jones for her time and participation in the meetings and presented her with a plaque. Board members took the opportunity to thank Ms. Jones for her service and commitment.
B.6. Agenda Review and Adoption (Public Comment)
Actions:
Motion
Ms. Kronenberg moved approval of the agenda as amended. Mr. Panas seconded. Ms. Kronenberg, Mr. Panas, Mr. Phillips, Student Representative Angel Jones (advisory vote only), and President Block voted yes. Ms. Cuevas was absent. Motion carried 4-0-0-1. Passed with a motion by Madeline Kronenberg and a second by Mr. Tom Panas.
Vote:
Yes Liz Block.
Absent Valerie Cuevas.
Yes Madeline Kronenberg.
Yes Mr. Tom Panas.
Yes Mr. Mister Phillips.
Minutes:
Mr. Phillips requested items G.4, 6, 7, 10, 14, 15, 17 & 18 be pulled for discussion. Superintendent Duffy asked that items F.1, 3 & 4 be moved to discussion becoming items E.5, 6 & 7.
B.7. Minutes: January 3, 2017; January 4, 2017
Actions:
Motion
Mr. Panas moved approval of the Minutes of January 3, 2017 and January 4, 2017 as amended. Ms. Kronenberg seconded. Ms. Kronenberg, Mr. Panas, Mr. Phillips, Student Representative Angel Jones (advisory vote only), and President Block voted yes, with no abstentions. Ms. Cuevas was absent. Motion carried 4-0-0-0. Passed with a motion by Mr. Tom Panas and a second by Madeline Kronenberg.
Vote:
Yes Liz Block.
Absent Valerie Cuevas.
Yes Madeline Kronenberg.
Yes Mr. Tom Panas.
Yes Mr. Mister Phillips.
Minutes:
Mr. Panas asked that the January 3 Minutes reflect the two handouts that were distributed and requested they be posted along with the minutes. He also recalled the board bylaw was not necessary on Item 2. On page 15 of the January 4 Minutes, he requested the minutes reflect that the item did not go to the Facility Subcommittee. Mr. Phillips clarified the vote on the Dual Immersion Program at Washington was to expand the program and that the board did not consider eliminating traditional kindergarten.
Attachments:
Minutes 1-3-17 Retreat
Minutes 1-4-17
C. AWARDS AND RECOGNITIONS
C.1. Recognition of Pinole Valley High School band and orchestra teacher Erik Radkiewcz for being named one of the "50 Directors Who Make a Difference" by School Band and Orchestra magazine
Speaker:
Matthew Duffy, Superintendent
Comments:

Erik Radkiewicz, the band and orchestra teacher at Pinole Valley High School, was recognized as one the nation’s top band directors making a difference in their students’ lives.

School Band and Orchestra Magazine selected Mr. Radkiewicz to represent California in its 19th Annual “50 Directors Who Make a Difference.” The publication selected one music educator from each state based on nominations it received from current and former students, colleagues, peers, parents and other community members.

Financial Impact:

None

Minutes:
Superintendent Duffy recognized Erik Radkiewcz for being named one of the "50 Directors Who Make a Difference" by School Band and Orchestra magazine. Board members congratulated Mr. Radkiewcz and stood for pictures.

Public Comment:
None

Board Comment:
None
D. COMMITTEE COMMUNICATION
Quick Summary / Abstract:
(Education Code 35145.5; Government Code 54950 et seq.)
D.1. Superintendent's Report
Minutes:
Superintendent Duffy provided a report of activities in the District. President Block requested the Superintendent post his report on the website as it provided valuable information she felt the community would like to see.

D.2. Standing Reports
Comments:
Representatives of the following committees and employee unions are invited to provide a brief update to the Board.  Representatives from these groups need to sign up to speak prior to the beginning of this item on the agenda by submitting a “Request to Address the Board” form.  Five minutes may be allowed for each subcommittee or group listed below:

Academic Subcommittee                              Public Employees Local 1
Bayside Council PTAs                                    Safety and School Climate Committee
Citizens’ Bond Oversight Committee            School Supervisors Association Local 21
Facilities Subcommittee                                Technology Subcommittee
Governance Subcommittee                          United Teachers of Richmond
Ivy League Connection                                 West Contra Costa Administrators Association
                                                                      Youth Commission

Minutes:
Ivy League Connection. Don Gosney remarked that the group hosted interviews for the Vanderbilt Program selecting Cameron Grant and Evan Garrison from El Cerrito High, Maddie Schmidt and Joslyn Perez from Middle College High to receive scholarships, discussed fundraising efforts and informational meetings to be held with Board members.

Citizens' Bond Oversight Committee (CBOC). Don Gosney reported on CBOC activities, website issues the committee has been working through, and membership.

Student Representative Angel Jones departed the meeting approximately 6:20 p.m.

Bayside Council of PTAs. Leslie Reckler provided an update on the Korematsu campus and opportunity to provide feedback. She noted highlights from the teacher and community survey.

United Teachers of Richmond. President Demetrio Gonzalez provided information on the collaborative work being done with the District around high school class sizes. He praised the Superintendent on his work regarding benchmarks and assessments. He also commented on the nominee for U.S. Secretary of Education.

Ms. Cuevas joined the meeting at 7:14 p.m.
D.3. Request to Address the Board - Mr. Billy Alexander
Comments:

Mr. Alexander will address the Board regarding Black History programs.

Minutes:
Mr. Alexander addressed the Board regarding Black History month and the passage of AB ACR6. He asked if the Board would permit Black History programs to all grade levels and all schools, and to appoint a Black History Specialist to work with the community.

Ms. Rashidchi pointed out the list provided to the Board of Black History Programs that all grade levels and schools currently have in place.
D.4. WCCUSD Public Comment
Quick Summary / Abstract:

Members of the public are invited to speak to the Board about any matter that is not otherwise on the agenda and is related to issues affecting public education in the WCCUSD.  Approximately 30 minutes will be allocated for this item.  If there are more requests to speak than can be heard within this time limit, “WCCUSD Public Comment” will continue after Item G.  Individuals wishing to speak must submit a “WCCUSD Public Comment” form prior to the beginning of this item on the agenda.  

Depending on the number of persons who wish to speak, from one to three minutes will be allocated to each speaker at the discretion of the President of the Board in order to accommodate as many speakers as possible.  The Board cannot dialogue on any issues brought before it by the public that have not been previously agendized, but may refer these to staff for response and/or placement on future agendas.

Minutes:
Alex Beltran, Judy Greenspan, Kristen Jones, Raquel Antolin, Valerie Jameson, Petronila Fernandes, Ana Negrete Velasco, Jacob Gran, Demetrio Gonzalez, Martha Serrano, Doug Marquez, Ben Steinberg. Frances Teso, Founder Voices College Bound Language Academies presented their charter petition during the public comment period.
D.5. In Memory of Members of the School Community
Speaker:
Matthew Duffy, Superintendent
Comments:

The District would like to take time to recognize the contributions of members of our school community who have passed away.  The District requests the community to submit names to be reported as a regular part of each agenda.

Former school board member, Ms. Diana Easton, passed away in December.  Ms. Easton was a parent of students in the District, an active member of the PTA, and worked devotedly to support students and public schools.  She served two terms on the school board from 1991 – 1999 during the tenure of Superintendent Herbert M. Cole, Jr.  She held the seat of President in 1994 and 1999.  Ms. Easton was greatly beloved and respected for her courtesy, kindness and devotion to the students and the district.  When people remember her, they appreciate that she was able to listen to opinions, even those with which she disagreed, with patience and respect, and always conducted herself on the board in a dignified manner.  

Our thoughts go out to the family and friends in the loss of their loved one.

Financial Impact:

None

Minutes:
Superintendent Duffy recognized the contributions of members of the community who have passed away and led a moment of silence.
Public Comment:
None
Board Comment:
None
E. DISCUSSION ITEMS AND REPORTS
E.1. LCAP Goal 2, 3, and 4 Update
Speaker:
Nia Rashidchi, Interim Associate Superintendent PreK-Adult Education Operations
Comments:

Staff will give update on LCAP Goals 2, 3, and 4.

LCAP Goal 2: Improve instructional practice through professional development and professional learning communities at schools and recruiting and retaining high quality teachers and principals.

LCAP Goal 3: Increase parent and community engagement, involvement, and satisfaction.

LCAP Goal 4: Improve student engagement and climate outcomes, and allocate services to English Learner (EL) and Low Income (LI) students.

Actions:
Motion
Mr. Phillips moved to halt discussion of Item E.1 and move on to Item F.3 (which was moved to E. Discussion). Ms. Kronenberg seconded. Ms. Cuevas, Ms. Kronenberg, Mr. Panas, Mr. Phillips, and President Block voted yes, with no abstentions and no absences. Motion carried 5-0-0-0. Passed with a motion by Mr. Mister Phillips and a second by Madeline Kronenberg.
Vote:
Yes Liz Block.
Yes Valerie Cuevas.
Yes Madeline Kronenberg.
Yes Mr. Tom Panas.
Yes Mr. Mister Phillips.
Financial Impact:

None

Minutes:
Ms. Rashidchi and her team provided an update of Goals 2, 3, and 4 highlighting, successes, challenges and next steps for each goal. Site members provided their perspectives for each goal from the site level and their own views of successes, challenges and next steps. During site comments for Goal 4, the Board moved to halt the presentation and move to discussion of Item F.3.
The Board returned to hear the conclusion of the report. Ms. Rashidchi completed the report of Goal 4. Mr. Martin presented updated information of the VAPA Program.
Public Comment:
Alex Beltran, Valerie Jameson, Rigel Massaro
Board Comment:
Ms. Cuevas questioned staff if hitting the mark on systemic goals and the relationship to student learning to which Ms. Rashidchi responded.
The group discussed parent engagement, community partner support, transparency and outreach.
Mr. Phillips requested the union provide feedback on Goal 2. Mr. Gonzalez from UTR provided his perspective based on feedback from the teaching community.
Mr. Panas thanked staff for their report and the audience for their participation. He commented on the length of time it takes to receive data and suggested a separate Board session to look deeper into the LCAP numbers.
Ms. Kronenberg also thanked staff for their presentation and agreed an LCAP study session was needed. She also agreed that an elementary and secondary teacher should be included on the LCAP committee.
President Block stated her appreciation of the presentation and enthusiasm of the presenters. She would also like a Board study session for LCAP.

MOTION: Mr. Phillips moved to extend the meeting for 30 minutes. Mr. Panas seconded the motion. Ms. Cuevas, Ms. Kronenberg, Mr. Panas, Mr. Phillips and President Block voted yes, with no abstentions and no absences. Motion carried 5-0-0-0.

The Board discussed remaining items tabling item E.2 to a future meeting and the possibility of suspending the Bylaws for a hard stopping time.

MOTION: Ms. Kronenberg made the motion to suspend the hard stopping time. Mr. Panas seconded the motion. Ms. Cuevas, Ms. Kronenberg, Mr. Panas, Mr. Phillips and President Block voted yes, with no abstentions and no absences. Motion carried 5-0-0-0.

President Block continued the meeting with item E.5 (formally action item F.1 which was moved to discussion).
Attachments:
LCAP Goal Overview
E.2. Discussion and Direction Regarding the Update of the District’s Educational Specifications
Speaker:
Lisa LeBlanc, Associate Superintendent Facilities, M&O, Bond
Comments:

 On June 15, 2016, the Board approved the Facilities Master Plan and the associated implementation plan.  The implementation plan included the direction to update the District’s Educational Specifications which were last approved in 2011.  The Educational Specifications guide the District’s architects to design and align school facilities to the educational program.  The architect uses the specifications to translate curriculum and instructional program into an aesthetic, economical, functional educational environment.  The update of the educational specifications also includes a comprehensive review of the materials and products that are incorporated into the school facilities.  This entire process was needed to provide consistency, alignment with current and future program needs and objectives, along with an emphasis on cost efficiency and effectiveness. 

On August 10, 2016, the Board approved an agreement with Educational Planning and Programming (Iep2) to update the Educational Specifications.  Since that time, the planning team has conducted over 20 focus group discussions regarding program spaces and comparing traditional and flexible designs.  At the same time, several discussions were held regarding the materials and products used in our schools and ways in which to refine, define, and create cost efficiencies.  From these discussions, the desire for a new flexible design for classrooms was explored.

The planning team, along with staff, will lead a discussion with the Board to seek direction regarding their desire to include flexible design options in future schools, whether or not to include the new options into the design of Wilson Elementary and any upcoming elementary school projects in the future.  After direction from the Board, the planning team will move forward with drafting the educational specifications and material/product standards and bring back a full draft report to the Board.

It should also be noted that the agreement with Iep2 was to have final review and approval of the Educational Specifications by the Board in January, 2017.  Due to the extensive focus group discussions on the new design concept, it will be necessary to extend the Iep2 agreement to concur with an updated timeline based upon the discussion held with the Board.

Minutes:
This item was tabled to future meeting.
Attachments:
Educational Specifications
E.3. Budget Development and Financial Reports Calendar
Speaker:
Sheri Gamba, Associate Superintendent Business Services
Comments:

Staff will present information on the timeline for 2017-18 budget development and 2016-17 financial reports.

Financial Impact:

None

Minutes:
Ms. Gamba shared the calendar asking the Board if they plan to hold study sessions as in the past. She will plan for both budget and LCAP if the Board chooses.
Mr. Panas requested the DBEC meeting be included in the calendar. Ms. Cifelli clarified that DBEC meeting dates were chosen after the budget calendar was prepared, but would be added.
Mr. Phillips previously requested a breakdown of housekeeping and professional services. Ms. Gamba will provide.
Public Comment:
None
Board Comment:
None
Attachments:
2017-18 Budget Development Calendar
E.4. Approve BP 7412.5 Debt Issuance and Investment Management Policy - First Reading
Speaker:
Sheri Gamba, Associate Superintendent Business Services
Comments:

On September 12, 2016 Governor Brown signed into law Senate Bill 1029 (Hertzberg). This bill requires state and local government debt issuers to report to the California Debt and Investment Advisory Commission (CDIAC) specified information about proposed and outstanding debt. Additionally, SB 1029 requires CDIAC to consult with appropriate state and local debt issuers and organizations representing debt issuers prior to approving any annual method of reporting.

The State Treasurer’s recent efforts to review how debt issuers manage and spend debt proceeds suggests that current debt reporting requirements provide insufficient transparency and accountability for how some governments handle their debt proceeds.  SB 1029 imposes some additional reporting requirements on debt issuers that will benefit taxpayers, investors, and public agencies.

Effective January 1, 2017, state and local issuers will be required to submit an annual debt report for any issue of debt for which they have submitted a Report of Final Sale during the reporting period. The annual debt report is due to CDIAC within seven (7) months of the close of the reporting period, defined as July 1st to June 30th. Because of the effective date of SB 1029, issuers who submit a Report of Final Sale after January 21, 2017 will be required to submit an annual debt report no later than seven (7) months after June 30, 2017 or on or before January 31, 2018.


Financial Impact:

None

Minutes:
Ms. Gamba introduced Graham Beck, bond counsel from Nixon, Peabody, LLC. He provided a high-level explanation of SB 1029 and how he was able to weave it into the existing debt policy to ensure compliance.
Public Comment:
None
Board Comment:
Members expressed their satisfaction with the policy and asked that it to be brought back for action.
Attachments:
BP 7412.5 Attachment 011817
F. ACTION ITEMS
F.1. Dual Immersion Program
Speaker:
Matthew Duffy, Superintendent
Comments:

At the last Board meeting, the Board approved the expansion of Dual Immersion programs in the District including a new mandarin immersion program.  Tonight we will hear more details about the proposed Mandarin Immersion program.  Details will include location, cost and program. The Board will be asked to take action on the item.

Financial Impact:
  • Staffing costs would be the same regardless of location unless an “existing school” was converted to Mandarin  (approximately $600,000)
  • Startup costs for supplies, instructional materials, etc. would come out of one-time fund balance as approved in December (approximately $200,000)
  • Playground and outdoor community space improvements would be paid through MRAD (approximately $200,000)
  • Facilities costs at Portola are minimal.  The projected cost to modify/improve existing portables would be covered by developer fees (approximately $200,000)
  • Bond funds would NOT be used for this project with the exception of funds ultimately needed to co-locate Wilson ES, i.e. PGE service upgrades; replacing portables that were removed for other district purposes
Minutes:
Superintendent Duffy reminded the group the item had been moved to Discussion and would be discussed as Item E.5.
Superintendent Duffy presented information on the proposed mandarin immersion program highlighting enrollment, staffing, location and costs.
Public Comment:
Malaysia Paradise, Pier Sun Ho, Tiffany Chieudjui, Leslie Reckler, Maria Gonzalez, Christopher Larsen, Denise Jones, Robert Ellis, Maisha Cole, Cindy Wu, Reichi Lee,
Board Comment:
Ms. Kronenberg addressed parents from Wilson asking Ms. LeBlanc to provide more detailed information on what has transpired. There was a question raised about funding utilizing reserve and members weighed in on the pros and cons the program might mean to the District and its resources.
President Block apologized for the assumptions and miscommunication parents from Wilson and Washington have experienced.
Superintendent Duffy discussed logistics for upcoming site renovations and thoughts behind the use of the Portola campus. He also requested clear direction from the Board for this item to be brought back as discussion or action.
Mr. Phillips asked staff to cost out moving Wilson early.
Ms. Kronenberg clarified the funds to move Wilson was already in the plan. She said she would like to see is the administrative costs to be added to the immersion classes.
Attachments:
Mandarin Immersion School
F.2. Certificated Provisional Internship Permit (PIP) Request(s)
Speaker:
Ken Whittemore, Assistant Superintendent Human Resources
Comments:
The Provisional Internship Permit (PIP) was created in response to the phasing out of emergency permits and became effective on July 1, 2005. It allows an employing agency to hire an individual who has not yet met the subject matter competence requirement needed to enter an internship program. Prior to requesting a PIP, the employing agency must verify that a diligent search has been made, and a fully credentialed teacher cannot be found. The PIP is issued for one year only.
Actions:
Motion
Mr. Panas moved approval of the adoption of the Certificated Provisional Internship Permit (PIP) Request(s). Ms. Kronenberg seconded. Ms. Cuevas, Ms. Kronenberg, Mr. Panas, Mr. Phillips, and President Block voted yes, with no abstentions and no absences. Motion carried 5-0-0-0.Recommend Approval Passed with a motion by Mr. Tom Panas and a second by Madeline Kronenberg.
Vote:
Yes Liz Block.
Yes Valerie Cuevas.
Yes Madeline Kronenberg.
Yes Mr. Tom Panas.
Yes Mr. Mister Phillips.
Minutes:
Mr. Whittemore provided detail on the request for Mr. Francisco Vicente to obtain a Provisional Internship Permit for Verde Elementary.
Public Comment:
Alex Beltran
Board Comment:
None
Attachments:
Provisional Intern Permit (PIP)
F.3. Revised Board Policy 5116.1 Intradistrict Open Enrollment
Speaker:
Steve Collins, Special Education
Comments:

California School Boards Association (CSBA) provides periodic updates to School Districts concerning Board Policies.  Also, due to the enactment of the Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) which replaced No Child Left Behind (NCLB) revisions were needed to be aligned with state and federal laws.

BP 5116.1 (Intradistrict Open Enrollment) needed to be revised due to the enactment of the Every Student Succeeds Act (“ESSA”), which replaced No Child Left Behind (“NCLB”).  One significant change was the elimination of the requirement that school districts allow students at schools receiving Title 1 funds identified for program improvement to transfer to another district school or charter school.  In addition, revisions were made to more closely align BP 5116.1 with District practice and procedures.  

Financial Impact:

None

Minutes:
President Block reminded everyone this item was moved to discussion item E.6.
Mr. Collins introduced Shawn Olson Brown from Fagan, Friedman & Fulfrost, attorney for Special Education and Student Services who assisted with policy development. Mr. Collins then presented information on intradistrict enrollment and transfer information noting the reasons and areas for the policy change.
Public Comment: (this was a combination of speakers wishing to speak on items F.3 and F.4)
Alex Beltran, Eleanor Thompson, Charles Stewart, Amerya Green, Jalin Wiggins, Dortohy Cox, Chaja Randle, Giselle Taylor, Jador Morrow, Tailei Lattier, Sheryl Lane Desmangles, Ashton Desmangles, Ivan, Juanita Dixon, Ivy Winston, Idrissa Lattier, D.D. Farrell, Malaysia Paradise, Scottie Smith, Daniel Farrell, Kathleen Sullivan, Yolanda Lopez, Ausberto Beltran
Board Comment:
Mr. Phillips commented on the solidarity shown by parents and let them know they were heard. He also noted his child is a transfer student and he understood their issues. He clarified with Ms. Brown that the current district transfer policy was still in place allowing priority transfers to students in program improvement schools to which Ms. Brown agreed. Mr. Phillips stated his understanding that should the District decide to allow program improvement transfers that the District had the right to do so. Ms. Brown agreed but noted it may be unclear which schools are program improvement as the list was two years old.
Ms. Rashidchi added that students on NCLB transfers continued to be approved when the law was put into place.
Discussion continued relating to the application of the law and the effect on future students.
Mr. Panas asked if the item could be changed back to discussion based on the conversations. Discussion continued on what the District's path forward would be. At the conclusion of discussion Mr. Panas withdrew his motion.
Mr. Phillips motioned to move back to action and vote.
Attorney Harold Freiman recapped where the item stood noting that technically the item could be moved back to action but audience had been lost thinking no action would be taken. He also reiterated that by taking no action the current policy remains in effect.
Mr. Philips rescinded his motion to move to action.
President Block recapped that the item would remain as discussion with no changes in the current policy.
The Board returned to complete the presentation on agenda item E.1.
Attachments:
BP 5116.1
F.4. Revised Board Policy 5117 Interdistrict Attendance
Speaker:
Steve Collins, Special Education
Comments:

California School Boards Association (CSBA) provides periodic updates to School Districts concerning Board Policies.  Also, due to the enactment of the Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) which replaced No Child Left Behind (NCLB) revisions were needed to be aligned with state and federal laws. 

BP 5117  (Interdistrict Attendance) was revised to reflect changes in the law related to criteria for interdistrict attendance and to more closely align with district practice and procedures.

Financial Impact:

None

Minutes:
Superintendent Duffy informed everyone this item was moved to discussion and would be discussed as Item E.7.

Public Comment:
None

Board Comment:
Mr. Panas and Mr. Phillips requested that the item be held over to a subsequent meeting to which the Board agreed.
Attachments:
BP 5117
G. BUSINESS ITEMS - CONSENT ITEMS
Actions:
Motion
Ms. Cuevas moved Approval of Consent Items G. 1-3, 5, 8-9, 11-13 and G.16. Mr. Panas seconded. Ms. Cuevas, Ms. Kronenberg, Mr. Panas, Mr. Phillips, and President Block voted yes, with no abstentions and no absences. Motion carried 5-0-0-0. Passed with a motion by Valerie Cuevas and a second by Mr. Tom Panas.
Vote:
Yes Liz Block.
Yes Valerie Cuevas.
Yes Madeline Kronenberg.
Yes Mr. Tom Panas.
Yes Mr. Mister Phillips.
Quick Summary / Abstract:

Consent Calendar Items are considered routine and will be enacted, approved and adopted by one motion, unless a request for removal, discussion or explanation is received from any Board member or member of the public in attendance. Items the Board pulls for discussion or explanation will be addressed following disposition of the remaining Consent Items under Section G Consent Items.

G.1. Grants/Awards/Agreements
Speaker:
Sheri Gamba, Associate Superintendent Business Services
Comments:

Formal action is requested from the Board of Education to accept the grants/awards/agreements, as detailed on the attached sheet dated January 18, 2017. 

Financial Impact:

As noted per grants summary.


Attachments:
Grants Summary 011817
G.2. Acceptance of Donations
Speaker:
Sheri Gamba, Associate Superintendent Business Services
Comments:
The District has received donations as summarized on the attached sheet dated January 18, 2017.  The estimated values for any non-cash donations (as indicated by an asterisk) are those provided by the donor.  Staff recommends acceptance of these donations.
Financial Impact:

As noted per donations summary.


Attachments:
Donations Summary 011817
G.3. Approval of Fund-Raising Activities
Speaker:
Sheri Gamba, Associate Superintendent Business Services
Comments:

The planned fund-raising events for the 2016-17 school year is summarized on the attached sheet dated January 18, 2017.

Financial Impact:
Additional revenue for schools

Attachments:
Fund Raising Summary 011817
G.4. Contracts
Speaker:
Sheri Gamba, Associate Superintendent Business Services
Comments:

Permission is requested of the Board of Education to approve the following contracts as detailed on the attached sheets dated January 18, 2017.

Actions:
Motion
Mr. Panas moved Approval of Consent Items G. 4. Ms. Kronenberg seconded. Ms. Cuevas, Ms. Kronenberg, Mr. Panas, Mr. Phillips, and President Block voted yes, with no abstentions and no absences. Motion carried 5-0-0-0. Passed with a motion by Mr. Tom Panas and a second by Madeline Kronenberg.
Vote:
Yes Liz Block.
Yes Valerie Cuevas.
Yes Madeline Kronenberg.
Yes Mr. Tom Panas.
Yes Mr. Mister Phillips.
Financial Impact:

As noted per contracts summary


Minutes:
This item was pulled for separate discussion and action
.
Mr. Phillips questioned start date of the contract. Mr. Whittemore explained the billing cycle. Members expressed the importance of seeing contracts prior to start date. Ms. Gamba provided input on the process and work being done with departments submitting.
Attachments:
1. Contracts Summary 011817
2. Contracts Back-Up 011817
G.5. Summary of Payroll and Vendor Warrant Reports
Speaker:
Sheri Gamba, Associate Superintendent Business Services
Comments:

Attached are the summaries of Payroll and Vendor Warrants issued during the months of November and December 2016.

               Total of payroll warrants (November 2016):           $ 11,324,242
               Total of vendor warrants (November 2016):           $ 26,309,935                 Total of payroll warrants (December 2016):           $ 11,507,371
               Total of vendor warrants (December 2016):           $ 24,962,987 

Financial Impact:

As noted above


Attachments:
1. Nov Payroll & Vendor Warrants Summaries
2. Dec Payroll & Vendor Warrants Summaries
G.6. Resolution 58-1617 Expenditures for Employee and Volunteer Recognitions
Speaker:
Marcus Walton, Communications Director
Comments:

California Education Code §44015 expressly authorizes the Board of Education to budget funds for the recognition of District employees. By passing this resolution, the Board of Education, in keeping with Education Code, would authorize the Superintendent to expend funds to recognize employees for their work on behalf of students and the District.

Financial Impact:

To be determined

Minutes:
This item was pulled for separate discussion and action. Due to the lateness of the meeting, this item was held over to the next meeting.

Attachments:
Resolution No. 58-1617
G.7. Memorandum of Understanding between the District and Sunny Ivy Education
Speaker:
Nia Rashidchi, Interim Associate Superintendent, PreK-Adult Education Operations
Comments:

The District would like to adopt a memorandum of understanding (MOU) with Sunny Ivy Education, a California corporation, to establish a short term cultural exchange program. This program involves the hosting by the District of a group of 11 visiting students from China at Korematsu Middle School from February 8 -10, 2017. The MOU is limited in duration, and will end February 17, 2017.

The primary purpose of this MOU is to afford students of West Contra Costa Unified School District and Sunny Ivy Education the opportunity to build cross cultural understanding between the United States and China.

Sunny Ivy will pay negotiated fees to the District for the investment of staff time and resources. 

Actions:
Motion
Ms. Block moved Approval of Consent Item G.7 with the agreement Counsel will again review the limits. Ms. Kronenberg seconded. Ms. Cuevas, Ms. Kronenberg, Mr. Panas, Mr. Phillips, and President Block voted yes, with no abstentions and no absences. Motion carried 5-0-0-0. Passed with a motion by Liz Block and a second by Madeline Kronenberg.
Vote:
Yes Liz Block.
Yes Valerie Cuevas.
Yes Madeline Kronenberg.
Yes Mr. Tom Panas.
Yes Mr. Mister Phillips.
Financial Impact:

None

Minutes:
This item was pulled for separate discussion and action.
Mr. Phillips questioned the insurance amount. Ms. Rashidchi advised that counsel had reviewed and explained coverage, noting that coverage for students is only while on campus. Their agency covers for travel and while off campus.
Ms. Kronenberg said it seemed low and would like counsel to take another look. She wanted to be sure this is standard for this type of travel.
Ms. Rashidchi will have counsel look at the coverage again and provide the information in a Friday memo.
Attachments:
MOU for Exchange Program
G.8. Routine Personnel Changes - Certificated
Speaker:
Ken Whittemore, Assistant Superintendent, Human Resources
Comments:
Routine personnel changes include actions to hire, promote, or terminate certificated employees in accordance with appropriate laws, established policies and procedures.
Attachments:
Certificated Personnel Changes
G.9. Classified Employee Ratification
Speaker:
Ken Whittemore, Assistant Superintendent-Human Resources
Comments:

Routine personnel changes include actions to hire, promote, or terminate classified employees in accordance with appropriate laws, established policies and procedures.

Financial Impact:

None

Attachments:
Classified Personnel Changes
G.10. Resolution 57-1617: Authorizing Competitive Negotiations for Erate Priority One Data Circuits and Managed VoIP Services pursuant to Public Contract Code Section 20118.2
Speaker:
Mary Phillips, Chief Technology Officer
Comments:

The District desires to go to bid for ERATE priority one data circuits and managed Voice over IP services.  The award will comply with the Public Contract Code 20118.2 which allows the District to select the most qualified bidder(s) whose bid meets the evaluation standards determined by the District and will be the most advantageous to the District with price and all other factors considered or to reject all responses to the Request for Bids, whichever is in the best interest of the District.  The District further reserves the right to award specific items or services on an individual per line item basis to one or more of the bidders, whichever is in the best interest of the District.  The successful bidder will be notified in the event of an award.  All bidders shall be assessed based on the specific needs of the District and the District will follow the competitive negotiation process described in Public Contract Code section 20118.2. 

Public Contract Code section 20018.2 was created due to the highly specialized and unique nature of technology, telecommunications, related equipment, software, and services.  Because products and materials of that nature are undergoing rapid technological changes, and in order to allow for the introduction of new technological changes into the operations of the school district, it is in the public’s best interest to allow a school district to consider, in addition to price, factors such as performance reliability, standardization, life-cycle costs, delivery timetables, support logistics, the broadest possible range of competing products and materials available, fitness of purchase, manufacture’s warranties, and similar factors in the award of contracts for technology, telecommunications, related equipment, software, and services.

Actions:
Motion
Mr. Phillips moved Approval of Consent Item G. 10. Mr.Panas seconded. Ms. Cuevas, Ms. Kronenberg, Mr. Panas, Mr. Phillips, and President Block voted yes, with no abstentions and no absences. Motion carried 5-0-0-0. Passed with a motion by Mr. Mister Phillips and a second by Mr. Tom Panas.
Vote:
Yes Liz Block.
Yes Valerie Cuevas.
Yes Madeline Kronenberg.
Yes Mr. Tom Panas.
Yes Mr. Mister Phillips.
Financial Impact:
No fiscal impact or implications associated with the approval of these documents.
Minutes:
This item was pulled for separate discussion and action.
Ms. Phillips stated the RFP had been issued and bids were due the second week of February.
Mr. Phillips questioned whether the RFP went to the Technology Subcommittee. Ms. Phillips stated it had and provided the timeline.
Attachments:
Resolution 57-1617 Authorizing Competitive Negotiations
G.11. Ratification of Negotiated Change Orders
Speaker:
Lisa LeBlanc, Associate Superintendent Facilities, M&O, Bond
Comments:

Staff is seeking ratification of Change Orders on the following current District construction projects:  Infrastructure Upgrades @ Kennedy HS, Richmond HS, Crespi MS and Pinole Valley HS New Campus. Change Orders are fully executed by the District upon signature by the Superintendent’s designee.  Board ratification is the final step required under state law in order to complete payment and contract adjustment.

In accordance with Public Contract Code 20118.4, the Board, by ratifying these Change Orders, finds that it would have been futile to publicly bid the work in question because of the tight time frames to complete this work without affecting the operations of the District, and that the public is best served by having this work completed by the contractor on the project.

Financial Impact:

Total ratification by this action:  $37,476.56. Funded from Bond Fund

Attachments:
Change Order Approval Table
G.12. Citizens’ Bond Oversight Committee (CBOC) Appointment: Davis Todhunter
Speaker:
Lisa LeBlanc, Associate Superintendent Facilities, M&O, Bond
Comments:

The West Contra Costa Unified School District’s Facilities Subcommittee has forwarded a recommendation that Davis Todhunter be appointed to fill the category of the City of El Cerrito resident on the West Contra Costa Unified School District Citizens’ Bond Oversight Committee for a two-year term effective January 18, 2017.

Financial Impact:

 None

Attachments:
Davis Todhunter's Application
G.13. Citizens’ Bond Oversight Committee (CBOC) Appointment: Sallie DeWitt
Speaker:
Lisa LeBlanc, Associate Superintendent Facilities, M&O, Bond
Comments:

The West Contra Costa Unified School District’s Facilities Subcommittee has forwarded a recommendation that Sallie DeWitt be appointed to fill the category of the Business Organization member on the West Contra Costa Unified School District Citizens’ Bond Oversight Committee for a two-year term effective January 18, 2017.

Financial Impact:

 None

Attachments:
Sallie DeWitt's Application
G.14. Williams Lawsuit Complaints Quarterly Report
Speaker:
Lisa LeBlanc, Associate Superintendent Facilities, M&O, Bond
Comments:

The Williams Lawsuit requires that a quarterly report be brought before the Board of Education reflecting the number of complaints filed with any school in the district during a particular quarter.   This report reflects the time period from October 1, 2016 through December 31, 2016.  Additional information can be viewed in the Superintendent’s office.

Financial Impact:

None

Minutes:
This item was pulled for separate discussion and action. Due to the lateness of the meeting, this item was held over to the next meeting.
Attachments:
Williams Quarterly Uniform Complaint Form
G.15. Ratification of Board Committee Liaison Roster
Speaker:
Matthew Duffy, Superintendent
Comments:

At their recent retreats in December and January, the Board determined assignments for 2017 including Board Subcommittees and Liaisons, as well as High School Families. 

Financial Impact:

None

Minutes:
This item was pulled for discussion. Due to the lateness of the meeting, this item was held over to the next meeting.
Attachments:
Board Assignments 2017
G.16. Approval of Board Member Travel
Speaker:
Matthew Duffy, Superintendent
Comments:

Board Bylaw 9250 stipulates members of the board shall be reimbursed for allowable expenses incurred in attending any meetings or in making any trips on official business of the school district when so authorized in advance by the Board of Education.  (Education Code 35044).  Board members have expressed interest in attend the following:

  • CSBA Presidents Workshop, Sacramento, January 28, 2017
  • CSBA Brown Act Workshop, Sacramento, January 27, 2016
  • Institute for New & First Term Board Members, Sacramento, January 27-28, 2017

Cost estimates for In-State Travel include registration and hotel are $1,229.80.

Financial Impact:

Estimated costs of $1220.80 from General Fund In-State Travel budget leaving  $14,935.00 in the budget.  


G.17. Resolution No. 60-1617: African American History Month
Speaker:
Marcus Walton, Communications Director
Comments:

The State Board of Education has proclaimed February 2017 as African American History Month. The West Contra Costa Unified School District recognizes the contributions of African Americans and encourages schools to develop special instructional activities and celebrations.

Financial Impact:

None

Minutes:
This item was pulled for separate discussion and action. Due to the lateness of the meeting, this item was held over to the next meeting.
Attachments:
Resolution 60-1617 African American History Month
G.18. Resolution No. 61-1617: Recognizing Fred T. Korematsu Day
Speaker:
Marcus Walton, Communications Director
Comments:

The State of California has proclaimed January 30, 2017, as  Fred Korematsu Day of Civil Liberties and the Constitution. The West Contra Costa Unified School District recognizes the contributions of Mr. Korematsu and encourages schools to develop special instructional activities and celebrations.

Financial Impact:

None

Minutes:
This item was pulled for separate discussion and action. Due to the lateness of the meeting, this item was held over to the next meeting.
Attachments:
Resolution No. 61-1617 Recognition of Fred Korematsu Day
H. UNFINISHED REQUESTS TO ADDRESS THE BOARD
Minutes:
None
I. THE NEXT SCHEDULED BOARD OF EDUCATION MEETING
Quick Summary / Abstract:

Lovonya DeJean Middle School - February 1, 2017


Minutes:
Lovonya DeJean - February 1, 2017
J. COMMENTS FROM THE BOARD OF EDUCATION AND FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
Minutes:
None
K. ADJOURNMENT
Quick Summary / Abstract:

At 10:00 PM, any items remaining on the agenda that require immediate attention will be moved to this time.  All other items will be tabled to another or the following Board meeting in order to make fair and attentive decisions.  The meeting will adjourn at 10:30 PM.  The meeting may be extended by a majority vote of the Board of Education.

Minutes:
President Block adjourned the meeting at 12:27 AM.

Disability Information:
Special Accommodations: Upon written request to the District, disability-related modifications or accommodations, including auxiliary aids or services, will be provided. Please contact the Superintendent’s Office at 510-231-1101 at least 48 hours in advance of meetings.
1/18/2017 6:42:00 PM ( Original )
PresentLiz Block
AbsentValerie Cuevas
PresentMadeline Kronenberg
PresentMr. Tom Panas
PresentMr. Mister Phillips
1/18/2017 7:14:00 PM
PresentValerie Cuevas

The resubmit was successful.