banner

Board of Education Regular Meeting
West Contra Costa USD
January 03, 2018 6:30PM
LOVONYA DEJEAN MIDDLE SCHOOL 3400 MACDONALD AVENUE RICHMOND, CA 94805

A. CLOSED SESSION
A.1. CALL TO ORDER
A.2. DISCLOSURE OF ITEMS TO BE DISCUSSED IN CLOSED SESSION - (Government Code 54957.7)
A.3. RECESS TO CLOSED SESSION AS SCHEDULED
Quick Summary / Abstract:

The Board will convene at 4:30 PM in the Multi-Purpose Room to receive comments from anyone wishing to address the Board regarding closed session items.  The Board will then adjourn to closed session and reconvene in open session to address the regular agenda at 6:30 PM.



A.3.1. CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL-ANTICIPATED LITIGATION/SIGNIFICANT EXPOSURE TO LITIGATION [Government Code Section 54956.9(d)(2) or (d)(3)]
Quick Summary / Abstract:

Two cases

A.3.2. CONFERENCE WITH LABOR NEGOTIATORS
Quick Summary / Abstract:

WCCUSD Negotiators: Superintendent Matthew Duffy and Assistant Superintendent Ken Whittemore for the following groups:
  a.    Employee Organizations
         -Adult School Teachers United (ASTU)
         -UTR
         -School Supervisors Association
         -Teamsters Local 856
         -WCCAA
 b.     Unrepresented Employees
         -Confidential and Management

A.3.3. STUDENT DISCIPLINE (Education Code Section 35146)
Quick Summary / Abstract:

Expulsions - One



A.3.4. REPORT OF CLOSED SESSION ACTIONS
B. OPENING PROCEDURES
Actions:
Motion
Passed with a motion by Tom Panas and a second by Madeline Kronenberg.
Vote:
Yes Liz Block.
Yes Valerie Cuevas.
Yes Madeline Kronenberg.
Yes Tom Panas.
Yes Mister Phillips.
Minutes:
President Cuevas called the meeting to order at 4:30 PM. The Board recessed into Closed Session. President Cuevas called the Public Session to order at 6:48 PM.
B.1. Pledge of Allegiance
Minutes:
President Cuevas led the Pledge of Allegiance.
B.2. Welcome and Meeting Procedures
Minutes:
President Cuevas offered welcome and instructions to the public regarding the meeting.
B.3. Roll Call
Minutes:
Board Members Present: Liz Block, Valerie Cuevas, Madeline Kronenberg, Tom Panas, Mister Phillips, and
Student Representatives Ryan Saechao. Student Representative Carol Linares was absent.

Staff Present: Eric Acosta-Verprauskus, Verde Principal; Katherine Acosta-Verprauskus, Montalvin Principal; Julio Arroyo, Executive Director M & O; Mark Bonnett, Executive Director Bond Finance; Alicia Bowman, Executive Director Research, Accountability, Assessment and Data; Steve Butler, Electronics Technician; Denise Cifelli, Confidential Secretary; Steve Collins, Associate Superintendent Special Education; Matthew Duffy, Superintendent; Jawan Eldridge, Peres Principal; Otilia Espinoza, Translator; Juan Carlos Field, Translator; Luis Freese, Engineering Officer; April Hawkins, LCAP Administrator; Debbie Haynie, Executive Secretary; Nancy Ingram, Staff Secretary; Robert Jordan, Manager Communications; Lisa LeBlanc, Associate Superintendent Facilities, M & O/Bond Program; Roxanna Molina, Translator; Chris Mount-Benites, Associate Superintendent Business Services; Melissa Payne, Director Contract Administration; Mary Phillips, Chief Technology Officer; Nia Rashidchi, Associate Superintendent PreK-Adult Educational Operations; Joey Sundberg, King Principal; Claudia Velez, Wilson Principal; Marcus Walton, Communications Director; Regina Webber, Executive Director; Ken Whittemore, Assistant Superintendent Human Resources
B.4. Report/Ratification of Closed Session
Minutes:
The Board took no action to expel student number 332818 for Education Code violation 35146.
B.5. Review of Number of Requests to Address the Board For Comment On Individual Agenda Items
Minutes:
President Cuevas assessed the number of speakers signed up in consideration of adjusting the agenda.
B.6. Agenda Review and Adoption (Public Comment)
Actions:
Motion
Mr. Panas moved approval of the Agenda as amended. Ms. Kronenberg seconded. Ms. Block, Ms.Kronenberg, Mr. Panas, Mr. Phillips, Student Representative Ryan Saechao (advisory vote only), and President Cuevas voted yes. Motion passed 5-0-0-0. Passed with a motion by Tom Panas and a second by Madeline Kronenberg.
Vote:
Yes Liz Block.
Yes Valerie Cuevas.
Yes Madeline Kronenberg.
Yes Tom Panas.
Yes Mister Phillips.
Minutes:
Mr. Phillips requested that items D.1 and D.8 be pulled for further discussion and to table G.1. Ms. Block requested to table G.2. President Cuevas requested Awards and Recognitions be moved after B.6.
B.7. Minutes: November 15, 2017; December 6, 2017
Actions:
Motion
Mr. Panas moved approval of Minutes, November 15, 2017 as amended. Ms. Kronenberg seconded. Ms. Block, Ms. Kronenberg, Mr. Panas, Mr. Phillips, Student Representative, Ryan Saechao (advisory vote only), and President Cuevas voted yes, with no abstentions and no absences. Motion carried 5-0-0-0. Passed with a motion by Tom Panas and a second by Madeline Kronenberg.
Vote:
Yes Liz Block.
Yes Valerie Cuevas.
Yes Madeline Kronenberg.
Yes Tom Panas.
Yes Mister Phillips.
Motion
Mr. Panas moved approval of the Minutes, December 6, 2017 as amended. Ms. Kronenberg seconded. Ms. Block, Ms. Kronenberg, Mr. Panas, Mr. Phillips, Student Representative, Ryan Saechao (advisory vote only), and President Cuevas voted yes, with no abstentions and no absences. Motion carried 5-0-0-0. Passed with a motion by Tom Panas and a second by Madeline Kronenberg.
Vote:
Yes Liz Block.
Yes Valerie Cuevas.
Yes Madeline Kronenberg.
Yes Tom Panas.
Yes Mister Phillips.
Minutes:
Mr. Phillips and Mr. Panas recommended amendments to the November 15 Minutes.

Mr. Panas pointed out corrections to the December 6 Minutes.
Attachments:
December 6, 2017
November 15, 2017
B.8. Request to Address the Board - Dr. Fatima Alleyne
Speaker:
Matthew Duffy, Superintendent
Comments:

Contra Costa County Board of Education Member Dr. Fatima Alleyne will provide an update of information about the County Office of Education.

Financial Impact:

None

Minutes:
Contra Costa County Board of Education Member and newly elected Board President Dr. Fatima Alleyne, accompanied by County Superintendent of Schools Karen Sakata, provided an update from the Contra Costa County Office of Education.
B.9. WCCUSD Public Comment
Quick Summary / Abstract:

Members of the public are invited to speak to the Board about any matter that is not otherwise on the agenda and is related to issues affecting public education in the WCCUSD.  Approximately 30 minutes will be allocated for this item.  If there are more requests to speak than can be heard within this time limit, “WCCUSD Public Comment” will continue after Item G.  Individuals wishing to speak must submit a “WCCUSD Public Comment” form prior to the beginning of this item on the agenda.  

Depending on the number of persons who wish to speak, from one to three minutes will be allocated to each speaker at the discretion of the President of the Board in order to accommodate as many speakers as possible.  The Board cannot dialogue on any issues brought before it by the public that have not been previously agendized, but may refer these to staff for response and/or placement on future agendas.

Minutes:
Adrianna Escoto, Christopher Larsen, Jen Komaromi, Ryan Bealer, LeDamien Flowers, Lesdia Ramirez, Maisha Cole, Juliette Wolk
C. AWARDS AND RECOGNITIONS
C.1. Recognition of the Hercules High School football team
Speaker:
Marcus Walton, Communications Director
Comments:

Under the leadership of coach Gerald Montgomery, the Hercules High School football team reached the North Coast Section Division 4 title game. The historic run included a 11-3 record. 


Financial Impact:

None

Minutes:
Superintendent Duffy provided information about the Hercules High School football team under the leadership of Coach Gerald Montgomery. The team reached the North Coast Section Division IV title game. The historic run included an 11-3 record. Superintendent Duffy presented a certificate to Coach Montgomery. Board members joined the team for a photo opportunity.
C.2. Recognition of Richmond High School soccer coach Rene Siles
Speaker:
Marcus Walton, Communications Director
Comments:

Tonight, the Board is honored to recognize Richmond High School soccer coach Rene Siles on the occasion of his 300th win as a head coach.  Silas has been a soccer coach since 1986 and has led teams at Richmond High School since 2000. His record at Richmond High School is now 301-70-49.

Financial Impact:

None

Minutes:
Superintendent Duffy provided information about the Richmond High School soccer coach Rene Siles on the occasion of his 300th win as head coach. Rene Silas has been a soccer coach since 1986 and has led teams at Richmond High School since 2000. His record at Richmond High School is now 301-70-49. Board members joined the coach and team for a photo opportunity.

D. BUSINESS ITEMS - CONSENT ITEMSWas edited within 72 hours of the Meeting
Actions:
Motion
Ms. Kronenberg moved approval of Consent Items D.2-7, D.9-10. Mr. Panas seconded. Ms. Block, Ms. Kronenberg, Mr. Panas, Mr. Phillips, Student Representative Ryan Saechao (advisory vote only), and President Cuevas voted yes, with no abstentions and no absences. Motion carried 5-0-0-0. Passed with a motion by Madeline Kronenberg and a second by Tom Panas.
Vote:
Yes Liz Block.
Yes Valerie Cuevas.
Yes Madeline Kronenberg.
Yes Tom Panas.
Yes Mister Phillips.
Quick Summary / Abstract:

Consent Calendar Items are considered routine and will be enacted, approved and adopted by one motion, unless a request for removal, discussion or explanation is received from any Board member or member of the public in attendance. Items the Board pulls for discussion or explanation will be addressed following Section G.

D.1. Grants/Awards/Agreements
Speaker:
Chris Mount-Benites, Associate Superintendent Business Services
Comments:

Formal action is requested from the Board of Education to accept the grants/awards/agreements, as detailed on the attached sheet dated January 3, 2018. 


Actions:
Motion
Ms. Block moved approval of D.1 Grants/Awards/Agreements. Mr. Panas seconded. Ms. Block, Ms. Kronenberg, Mr. Panas, Mr. Phillips, and President Cuevas voted yes, with no abstentions and no absences. Motion carried 5-0-0-0. Passed with a motion by Liz Block and a second by Tom Panas. Passed with a motion by Liz Block and a second by Tom Panas.
Vote:
Yes Liz Block.
Yes Valerie Cuevas.
Yes Madeline Kronenberg.
Yes Tom Panas.
Yes Mister Phillips.
Financial Impact:
As noted per grants summary.

Minutes:
This item was pulled for separate discussion and action.

Mr. Phillips had questions about the Peres Drop Out Prevention program. Superintendent Duffy explained the use of grant funds for the work to be done. Ms. Rashidchi also provided clarification.
Attachments:
Grants Summary 010318
D.2. Acceptance of Donations
Speaker:
Chris Mount-Benites, Associate Superintendent Business Services
Comments:

The District has received donations as summarized on the attached sheet dated January 3, 2018.  The estimated values for any non-cash donations (as indicated by an asterisk) are those provided by the donor.  Staff recommends acceptance of these donations.


Financial Impact:
As noted per donations summary.

Attachments:
Donations Summary 010318
D.3. Approval of Fund-Raising Activities
Speaker:
Chris Mount-Benites, Associate Superintendent Business Services
Comments:

The planned fund-raising events for the 2017-18 school year is summarized on the attached sheet dated January 3, 2018.

Financial Impact:

Additional revenue for schools.

Attachments:
Fund Raising Summary 010318
D.4. Annual Renewal of Continuing Services
Speaker:
Chris Mount-Benites, Associate Superintendent Business Services
Comments:

Permission is requested of the Board of Education to approve the following contracts for services as detailed on the attached sheets dated January 3, 2018.

Financial Impact:

As noted per contracts summary.

Attachments:
1. Continuing Contracts Summary 010318
2. Continuing Services Back-Up 010318
D.5. Summary of Payroll and Vendor Warrant Reports
Speaker:
Chris Mount-Benites, Associate Superintendent Business Services
Comments:

Attached are the summaries of Payroll and Vendor Warrants issued during the month of November 2017.

                Total of payroll warrants (November 2017):          $  12,179,404

                Total of vendor warrants (November 2017):           $  22,404,676

Financial Impact:

As noted above.

Attachments:
Payroll & Vendor Warrant Summaries 010318
D.6. Cultural Exchange Student VisitationWas edited within 72 hours of the Meeting
Speaker:
Nia Rashidchi, Associate Superintendent
Comments:

The District would like to adopt a memorandum of understanding (MOU) with PCC Education, a California corporation, to establish a short term cultural exchange program. This program involves the hosting by the District of a group of visiting students from China at Madera Elementary School, Korematsu Middle School, and De Anza High School for up to eight days from January 31 to February 9, 2018. The MOU is limited in duration, and will end byFebruary 28, 2018.

The primary purpose of this MOU is to afford students of West Contra Costa Unified School District and PCC Education the opportunity to build cross cultural understanding between the United States and China. This visit builds on previous efforts by the Madera, Korematsu, and De Anza communities to build cultural and academic exchange with schools in China.

PCC Education will pay negotiated fees to the District for the investment of staff time and resources.

Financial Impact:
None to the District.
Attachments:
MOU for Exchange Program Jan.31 - Feb. 9
D.7. Classified Employee Ratification
Speaker:
Ken Whittemore, Assistant Superintendent-Human Resources
Comments:

Routine personnel changes include actions to hire, promote or terminate classified employees in accordance with appropriate laws, established policies and procedures.

Financial Impact:

None

Attachments:
January 3 2018 Ratification
D.8. Update of Board Policies: BP 0410 Nondiscrimination In District Programs And Activities, BP 1312.3 Uniform Complaint Procedures, BP 5146 Married/Pregnant/Parenting Students - First Read
Speaker:
Matthew Duffy, Superintendent
Comments:

As a result of the recent Federal Program Monitoring review, Board Policy updates were recommended for the following:

BP 0410 Nondiscrimination In District Programs and Activities
BP 1312.3 1312.3 Uniform Complaint Procedures
BP 5146 Married/Pregnant/Parenting Students

In order to conform with legal compliance and provide students and families with accurate information via Board Policies, these updates are provided as a first read for the Board and public.  These policies will return on a subsequent Board agenda for approval.

Actions:
Motion
Mr. Phillips moved table of D.8 to future meeting. Mr. Panas seconded. Ms. Block, Ms. Kronenberg, Mr. Panas, Mr. Phillips, and President Cuevas voted yes, with no abstentions and no absences. Motion carried 5-0-0-0. Passed with a motion by Mister Phillips and a second by Tom Panas.
Vote:
Yes Liz Block.
Yes Valerie Cuevas.
Yes Madeline Kronenberg.
Yes Tom Panas.
Yes Mister Phillips.
Financial Impact:

None

Minutes:
This item was pulled for separate discussion and action.
Attachments:
BP 0410 Nondiscrimination in District Programs and Activities
BP 1312.3 Uniform Complaint Procedures
BP 5146 Married/Pregnant/Parenting Students
D.9. Ratification of Negotiated Bond Program Change Orders
Speaker:
Lisa LeBlanc, Associate Superintendent Facilities, M&O Bond
Comments:

Staff is seeking ratification of change orders on the following construction projects: Valley View Elementary School Partial Campus Demolition & Harmon Knolls Campus Demolition. Valley View Elementary School Partial Campus Demolition project change order includes a credit for scope of work omitted; demolition of one portable building. Harmon Knolls Campus Demolition project change order includes removal of additional sidewalk, additional chain link fencing and additional shrubs. Board ratification is required under state law in order to process the contract adjustment and complete payment.

In accordance with Public Contract Code 20118.4, the Board, by ratifying these Change Orders, finds that it would have been futile to publicly bid the work in question because of the tight time frames to complete this work without affecting the operations of the District, and that the public is best served by having this work completed by the contractor on the project.

Financial Impact:

Total ratification by this action: $6,393.75. Funded from Bond Fund. The change orders are within the Board Approved Site Budget.

Attachments:
Change Order Approval Table
D.10. Approval of Professional and Special Services Contracts
Speaker:
Lisa LeBlanc, Associate Superintendent Facilities, M&O, Bond
Comments:

Contracts and amendments have been initiated by staff using previously qualified consulting, engineering or architectural firms to assist in completion of the referenced projects. Public contracting laws have been followed in initially qualifying and selecting these professionals.

Financial Impact:

Total for this action: $332,666.  Funding sources are General Fund ($20,000), Cafeteria Fund 13 ($40,000), Bond Fund 21 ($228,106), and Capital Outlay Fund 40 ($44,560).  All proposed contracts and amendments are within the Board approved budget. 

01-8150-6202-615-0000-8500-400110-0-8151          $20,000

13-5310-5640-651-0000-3700-400140-0-0000          $40,000

21-9745-6201-146-0000-8500-400130-0-0000            $1,000

21-9745-6207-160-0000-8500-400130-0-0000          $11,860

21-9748-5860-615-0000-8500-400130-0-0000         $115,246

21-9748-6202-615-0000-8500-400130-0-0000         $100,000

40-0000-6202-615-0000-8500-400130-0-0000           $44,560

                                                                 Total          $332,666

Attachments:
1 Professional & Special Services Contracts
2 Amendments
E. COMMITTEE COMMUNICATION
Quick Summary / Abstract:
(Education Code 35145.5; Government Code 54950 et seq.)
E.1. Superintendent's Report
Minutes:
Mr. Duffy welcomed everyone back from holiday break and looked forward to a productive New Year.

Board Comment:
Mr. Phillips requested an update for the Positive School Climate policy. Mr. Duffy stated there would be a workshop on Friday, January 5, 2018. He will report back to the Board following that meeting.
F. DISCUSSION ITEMS AND REPORTS
F.1. Math Interim Assessments
Speaker:
Nia Rashidchi, Associate Superintendent, PreK-Adult Educational Services
Comments:
Staff will present on the baseline results of the Smarter Balanced Math Interim Assessment data grades 3 - 8.
Financial Impact:

None

Minutes:
Executive Director Dr. Sarah Breed and Coordinator Katie Von Husen presented results of the Smarter Balanced Math Interim Assessment data for grades 3-8.

Public Comment:
None

Board Comment:
Mr. Panas appreciated the executive summary and school numbers. He inquired what to expect with the next set of test results. Dr. Breed spoke of seeing a ten percent growth from previous scores to the next set of test scores.

Mr. Phillips stated he would like to see whether students had improved or regressed. Growth or regression would be informative for next presentation.

Ms. Kronenberg appreciated hard work from staff. She suggested better presentations for Board understanding. She would like to see more comparison and growth.

Ms. Block noted the next steps for students and what was needed for success.

Teachers Marissa Glidden and Merill Pierce shared their experiences and thoughts about testing done at Verde.
Attachments:
Math Interim Assessments
F.2. Board Bylaw 9012 Board Member Electronic Communications
Speaker:
Marcus Walton, Communications Director
Comments:

The California Supreme Court has held that a Board Members' writings and communications about public business are not excluded from a California Public Records Act (CPRA) request simply because they have been sent from, or received in, a personal account or personal device. (City of San Jose v. Superior Court (March 2, 2017) 2017 WL 818506.) In other words, regardless of whether board members communicate using the district email server or a private electronic method of communication, that communication may be subject to a CPRA request.

The proposed Board Bylaw outlines steps to ensure compliance with both the California Public Records Act and the Brown Act. In addition, the proposed bylaw would limit electronic communication by Board members during meetings of the Board.

Financial Impact:

None

Minutes:
Communications Director Marcus Walton provided background and cited the ruling of the California Supreme Court related to writing and communication about public business are not excluded from the California Public Records Act regardless of electronic devices used.

Mr. Panas shared information about review by the Governance Subcommittee.

Public Comment:
None

Board Comment:
Mr. Phillips expressed his concerns about attending Board meetings and not able to call/text family in case of an emergency. He said he agreed with the Bylaw as it relates to the Brown Act and no communication between Board members.

President Cuevas reiterated the point of the Bylaw about communication on any device for District business subjected to the California's Open Meetings Act.
Attachments:
BB 9012 Board Member Electronic Communications
G. ACTION ITEMS
Actions:
Motion
Mr. Panas moved to extend School Board Meeting by 1.5 hrs. Mr. Kronenberg seconded. Ms. Kronenberg, Mr. Panas, Mr. Phillips, and President Cuevas voted yes. Ms. Block voted no, with no abstentions and no absences. Motion passed 4-1-0-0. Passed with a motion by Tom Panas and a second by Madeline Kronenberg.
Vote:
No Liz Block.
Yes Valerie Cuevas.
Yes Madeline Kronenberg.
Yes Tom Panas.
Yes Mister Phillips.
G.1. Expansion of K-8 Schools
Speaker:
Matthew Duffy, Superintendent
Comments:

The Board will hear information about K-8 schools and be asked to vote on the expansion of three schools:  Montalvin, Verde, and Peres.  

The Superintendent will explain the rationale for K-8 schools and the decision behind these three schools at this time. 

Additional details will be presented.

Actions:
Motion
Mr. Phillips moved to table Expansion of K-8 Schools. Ms. Kronenberg seconded. A roll call vote was taken with Mr. Phillips voting yes, Ms. Block, Ms. Kronenberg, Mr. Panas, Student Representative Ryan Saechao (advisory vote only), and President Cuevas voting no, with no abstentions and no absences. Motion failed 1-4-0-0. Failed with a motion by Mister Phillips and a second by Madeline Kronenberg. Failed with a motion by Mister Phillips and a second by Madeline Kronenberg.
Vote:
No Liz Block.
No Valerie Cuevas.
No Madeline Kronenberg.
No Tom Panas.
Yes Mister Phillips.
Motion
Mr. Panas moved to table Expansion of K-8 Schools to the next school board meeting. Mr. Phillips seconded. A roll call vote was taken with Mr. Panas and Mr. Phillips voting yes, Ms. Block, Ms. Kronenberg, and President Cuevas voting no, with no abstentions and no absences. Motion failed 2-3-0-0. Failed with a motion by Tom Panas and a second by Mister Phillips. Failed with a motion by Tom Panas and a second by Mister Phillips.
Vote:
No Liz Block.
No Valerie Cuevas.
No Madeline Kronenberg.
Yes Tom Panas.
Yes Mister Phillips.
Motion
Ms. Kronenberg moved approval of the Expansion of K-8 Schools. Ms. Block seconded. A roll call vote was taken with Ms. Kronenberg, Ms. Block, and President Cuevas voting yes, Mr. Panas voting no, Mr. Phillips abstaining, and no absences. Motion passed 3-1-1-0. Passed with a motion by Madeline Kronenberg and a second by Liz Block. Passed with a motion by Madeline Kronenberg and a second by Liz Block.
Vote:
Yes Liz Block.
Yes Valerie Cuevas.
Yes Madeline Kronenberg.
No Tom Panas.
Abstain Mister Phillips.
Financial Impact:

Costs vary over time.  


Minutes:
President Cuevas noted the request from a Board member to consider tabling this item without discussion.

Mr. Phillips explained reasoning for the request until financial projections are provided by staff.

Superintendent Duffy offered clarification.

Superintendent Duffy and staff presented the criteria behind the recommendations to expand Montalvin, Peres and Verde elementaryschools to K-8 campuses, citing parent interest and positive staff surveys. Superintendent Duffy summarized financial considerations including facilities needs and impact to surrounding middle schools.

Student Representative Ryan Saechao left the meeting for the evening.

Public Comment:
Rachel Ricker, Israel Rodriguez, Martina Aguilar, Merill Pierce, Marissa Glidden, Jeff Allred

Board Comment:
Ms. Block noted middle school grades when the District can lose students to gangs. Students are vulnerable at this grade level. She stated the K-8 schools would stave off the intrusion of gangs. Students looking for family would find it at the K-8 schools.

Ms. Kronenberg stated this was an example of the District building on its strengths. The three schools met the criteria set up by the District before other schools would be considered.

Mr. Phillips stated financial data had not been presented to the Board. He could not make a decision without data. He noted in the presentation financial costs of $600,000, an unrealistic projection and felt costs would be higher.

Mr. Panas said he was concerned about the impact on Helms Middle School with loss of students. Superintendent Duffy stated the loss of 30-60 students would not impact the core structure. He said there was not enough financial analysis to warrant a decision.

President Cuevas talked about empathy for people when decisions are made. She noted that there are concerns about costs in all the Board decisions.
Attachments:
Expansion of K-8 Schools
G.2. Agreement for the Design and Construction of the Wilson Elementary School Replacement Project between the West Contra Costa Unified School District and C Overaa & Co
Speaker:
Lisa LeBlanc, Associate Superintendent Facilities, M&O, Bond
Comments:

Pursuant to California Education Code section 17250.10 et seq. (“Design-Build Statute”), the District advertised a Request for Qualifications for Design-Build Construction services on May 22, 2017, pursuant to which the District prequalified five (5) design-build firms (“Prequalified Firms”) for the Wilson Elementary School Replacement Project (“Project”). Thereafter, on September 1, 2017, the District issued a Request for Proposals (“RFP”) to invite the Prequalified Firms to submit competitive sealed proposals to design and build the Project. All Prequalified Firms submitted Proposals on September 29, 2017.

The Proposals were evaluated by the District’s Evaluation Committee - which consisted of District staff, Wilson Elementary School principal and PTA secretary as well as industry professionals- to determine which Proposal provided the “best value” to the District. The Committee’s review included evaluation of the objective criteria set forth in the RFP, including but not limited to, price, features, functions, life-cycle costs, experience, and past performance.  Additionally, the District held team presentations starting on October 10, 2017 wherein the Prequalified Firms presented proposed project details, means/method, schedule, and line item estimates.  Based on the Committee’s review and evaluation of the Proposals and team presentations, the Committee recommended award of the Agreement to the C Overaa & Co design-build entity as the firm offering the best value to the District for the Project.

Facilities staff presented the recommended team, design/project approach, and next steps to Facilities Subcommittee on November 14, 2017. The Facilities Subcommittee emphasized the importance and desire for local hire and local business utilization which is in the agreement.  Thereafter, Facilities staff met with Wilson staff and Wilson community to provide a project update. 

On December 19, 2017, staff recommended to the Facilities Subcommittee that the District enter into the Agreement with C Overaa & Co to design and construct Wilson Elementary School.  The Facilities Subcommittee recommended staff identify possible cost alternatives in the Board approved Material and Product Standards for Board consideration on January 3, 2018.

The Agreement provides for C Overaa & Co to perform the design and construction services required to complete the Project for a stipulated sum of Thirty Five Million One Hundred Thirteen Thousand Three Hundred Forty-Five Thousand Dollars ($35,113,345).




Actions:
Motion
Ms. Kronenberg moved approval of the Agreement for the Design and Construction of the Wilson Elementary School Replacement Project between the WCCUSD and C. Overaa & Co. Mr. Phillips seconded. A roll call vote was taken with Ms. Kronenberg, Mr. Panas, Mr. Phillips, and President Cuevas voting yes, Ms. Block abstained, and no absences. Motion carried 4-0-1-0. Passed with a motion by Madeline Kronenberg and a second by Mister Phillips. Passed with a motion by Madeline Kronenberg and a second by Mister Phillips.
Vote:
Abstain Liz Block.
Yes Valerie Cuevas.
Yes Madeline Kronenberg.
Yes Tom Panas.
Yes Mister Phillips.
Financial Impact:

  $35,113,345. (21-9745-6211-165-0000-8500-400130-0-0000).

Minutes:
Minutes:
President Cuevas noted the request to table this item. After consideration, the Board member declined to do so.

Associate Superintendent LeBlanc provided details regarding the process used to determine the construction company selected for the Wilson Design and Construction project. Mike Conrad and Lauren Moss were introduced and shared information about their companies. Ms. LeBlanc provided budget details of funding.

Public Comment:
Adrianna Escoto, Tom Waller, Maisha Cole, Juliette Wilk, Christopher Larsen, Sallie DeWitt, Nicolas Romano

Board Comment:
Ms. Kronenberg commented that the Wilson community had followed guidelines to move approval of the contract. They went through the design build and change orders would not to be a factor for the contract.

Mr. Phillips noted the lengthy wait for the Wilson community. He spoke of an issue of a show of respect from the Board to move forward with the contract. He commended the school community for being fantastic through the process.

Ms. Block noted school families are waiting for new schools with the Wilson community receiving a new campus. Ms. Block spoke emotionally about the high construction costs, Board choices, and consideration of families' needs.

Mr. Panas was happy about transparency throughout the process. He was concerned about the Wilson project bearing costs regarding the Portola site. Ms. LeBlanc said there currently were no plans for the Portola site to be used, but possibly in the future Mr. Panas was happy to hear the Wilson parents were willing to car pool to help reduce costs of busing.

President Cuevas noted the meetings held about specifications, material, products, and design of schools. The Facilities Master Plan had been developed to determined what to build next, budget, community process, and transparent to public. She had further comment about the process of the Master Plan.
Attachments:
G.2 1 Wilson Power Point
G.2 2 Wilson Contract
G.3. Approval of Short-term Health Benefits Premiums Agreement with Teamsters Union Local 856/ AB 1200 Public Disclosure
Speaker:
Ken Whittemore, Assistant Superintendent, Human Resources
Comments:

An agreement between the Teamsters Union Local 856 and the West Contra Costa Unified School District in regards to District and employee health benefit contributions.  Specifically, the parties agreed to raise the contribution rate from 80% of the Bay Area Kaiser rate for 2016 to 80% of the 2018 Bay Area Kaiser rate enact the following District health care contributions while the parties continue the collective bargaining process.

This agreement is directly correlated to the efforts of Teamsters 856 presenting the impact of January 2018 health care increases for employees during the negotiation process.  The West Contra Costa Unified School District Board of Education and the Superintendent recognize this impact and wish to use this short-term agreement as a springboard to future collaboration on a long-term agreement with our employees represented by Teamsters 856.

School districts are required to publicly disclose the provisions of all collective bargaining agreements before they ratify an agreement.  This ensures that the public is aware of the details associated with a tentative collective bargaining agreement before it becomes binding on the district.  A summary of the financial implications is attached.  This summary has been provided to the County Office of Education.

Actions:
Motion
Mr. Panas moved approval the Short-term Health Benefits Premiums Agreement with Teamsters Union Local 856/AB 1200 Public Disclosure. Ms. Kronenberg seconded. Ms. Block, Ms. Kronenberg, Mr. Panas, Mr. Phillips, and President Cuevas voted yes, with no abstentions and no absences. Motion carried 5-0-0-0. Passed with a motion by Tom Panas and a second by Madeline Kronenberg.
Vote:
Yes Liz Block.
Yes Valerie Cuevas.
Yes Madeline Kronenberg.
Yes Tom Panas.
Yes Mister Phillips.
Financial Impact:
$77,500-General Fund
Minutes:
Mr. Whittemore explained details and the five-year budget. He said that long term solutions are expected in March.

Public Comment:
None

Board Comment:
Mr. Panas said he was pleased with the five year projection.
Attachments:
AB-1200-Teamsters-WCCUSD-Health Benefits
G.4. Approval of the New Babysitter and Playground Supervisor Minimum Wage Agreement with Teamsters Local Union 856/AB 1200 Public DisclosureWas edited within 72 hours of the Meeting
Speaker:
Ken Whittemore, Assistant Suprintendent, Human Resources
Comments:

The West Contra Costa Unified School District and Teamsters Local Union 856 have engaged in discussions in regards to district babysitter and playground supervisor and minimum hourly wage pay of $13.60, effective January 1, 2018.

The negotiations on this item came to the forefront with the October 1, 2017 enactment allowing playground supervisor to join a bargaining unit.  The babysitter job class has also entered into the Teamsters 856 unit. Through negotiations, it was determined to update the wages of the employees who serve the District in these roles.

Specifically, the babysitters provide service and care at meetings that parents and community members would not be able to attend without the service.  The playground supervisors provide monitoring and oversight of playgrounds at elementary schools.

School districts are required to publicly disclose the provisions of all collective bargaining agreements before they ratify an agreement.  This ensures that the public is aware of the details associated with a tentative collective bargaining agreement before it becomes binding on the district.  A summary of the financial implications is attached.  This summary has been provided to the County Office of Education.



Actions:
Motion
Ms. Block moved Approval of the New Babysitter & Playground Supervisor Minimum Wage Agreement with Teamsters Local Union 856/AB 1200 Public Disclosure. Mr. Panas seconded. Ms. Block, Ms. Kronenberg, Mr. Panas, Mr. Phillips, and President Cuevas voted yes, with no abstentions and no absences. Motion carried 5-0-0-0. Passed with a motion by Liz Block and a second by Tom Panas.
Vote:
Yes Liz Block.
Yes Valerie Cuevas.
Yes Madeline Kronenberg.
Yes Tom Panas.
Yes Mister Phillips.
Financial Impact:
$33,354 General Fund
Minutes:
Mr. Whittemore provided details of the upgrades for the lowest paid classified staff.

Public Comment:
None

Board Comment:
Mr. Panas questioned the minimum wage. Mr. Phillips stated WCCUSD was a state agency that needed to follow state guide lines for the minimum wage laws.
Attachments:
AB-1200 Teamsters-WCCUSD
G.5. Presentation of the 2016 – 2017 Measure G Audit Report by Christy White & Associates
Speaker:
Chris Mount-Benites, Associate Superintendent Business Services
Comments:

The District’s auditing firm, Christy White & Associates, will present their independent audit report of the Measure G Parcel Tax for the year ended June 30, 2017.

The 2016-2017 Measure G Audit report is posted on the WCCUSD web site.

Actions:
Motion
Mr. Panas moved to accept the 2016-2017 Measure G Audit Report. Ms. Kronenberg seconded. Ms. Kronenberg, Mr. Panas, Mr. Phillips, and President Cuevas voted yes, with no abstentions, and Ms. Block absent. Motion carried 4-0-0-1. Passed with a motion by Tom Panas and a second by Madeline Kronenberg. Passed with a motion by Tom Panas and a second by Madeline Kronenberg.
Vote:
Absent Liz Block.
Yes Valerie Cuevas.
Yes Madeline Kronenberg.
Yes Tom Panas.
Yes Mister Phillips.
Financial Impact:

None

Minutes:
Lead Auditor Heather Rubio provided a presentation.

Public Comment:
None

Board Comment:
Mr. Panas thanked staff for the three year audit and spoke about the clean audit with new procedures in place. Ms. Kronenberg noted the deficiency with Associated Student Body funds. Ms. Rubio stated more training was needed and for people to get involved, become aware of rules, responsibilities, and controls in place.
Attachments:
2017 Measure G Parcel Tax Audit
Audit Powerpoint
G.6. Presentation of the 2016 – 2017 Audit Report by Christy White & Associates
Speaker:
Chris Mount-Benites, Associate Superintendent Business Services
Comments:

The District’s auditing firm, Christy White & Associates, will present their independent audit report of the West Contra Costa Unified School District’s financial position, internal control, and federal and state compliance for the year ended June 30, 2017.

The 2016-2017 Audit report is posted on the WCCUSD web site.

Actions:
Motion
Mr. Panas moved acceptance of the 2016-2017 Audit Report. Ms. Kronenberg seconded. Ms. Kronenberg, Mr. Panas, Mr. Phillips, and President Cuevas voted yes, with no abstentions, and Ms. Block absent. Motion carried 4-0-0-1. Passed with a motion by Tom Panas and a second by Madeline Kronenberg.
Vote:
Absent Liz Block.
Yes Valerie Cuevas.
Yes Madeline Kronenberg.
Yes Tom Panas.
Yes Mister Phillips.
Financial Impact:

None

Minutes:
Lead Auditor Heather Rubio provided a presentation.

Public Comment:
None

Board Comment:
None
Attachments:
2017 District Wide Audit Report
G.7. New Member Ratification for the Citizens Oversight Committee for Parcel Taxes
Speaker:
Chris Mount-Benites, Associate Superintendent Business Services
Comments:

At the October 18, 2017 meeting, the Board approved committee membership according to Board Policy 1221 Parcel Taxes. While not all of the organizations that are requested to provide a member have been able to do so, it is important to appoint the members who have been recommended. The Board is being asked to approve membership for Valerie Jameson, Youth Program Leader and Anton Jungherr who is replacing Jack Weir, Contra Costa County Taxpayers Association. The Board of Education will approve remaining nominations at a public meeting as they are received. Nomination forms are on file and available for viewing at the district office. 

The membership of the committee includes: 

PTA

Leslie Reckler

PTO Member

Waiting response from organization

Youth Commission

Waiting response from organization

Youth Program Leader

Valerie Jameson

Business Representative

Jenny Komaromi

Teacher

Elizabeth Bundschu-Mooney

Classified Employee

Francie Kunaniec

Principal

Jose DeLeon

California Charter Schools Representative

Rocio Gonzalez-Frausto

Contra Costa County Taxpayers Association Representative

Anton Jungherr

West County Mayors Association

Waiting response from organization

Actions:
Motion
Mr. Panas moved approval of the New Member Ratification for the Citizens Oversight Committee for Parcel Taxes. Ms. Kronenberg seconded. Ms. Block, Ms. Kronenberg, Mr. Panas, Mr. Phillips, and President Cuevas voted yes, with no abstentions and no absences. Motion carried 5-0-0-0. Passed with a motion by Tom Panas and a second by Madeline Kronenberg.
Vote:
Yes Liz Block.
Yes Valerie Cuevas.
Yes Madeline Kronenberg.
Yes Tom Panas.
Yes Mister Phillips.
Financial Impact:

None

Minutes:
Public Comment:
None

Board Comment:
None
G.8. Adopt Resolution No.54-1718 Budget Revisions, Resulting Increases and/or Decreases in Appropriations for the 2017-18 Budget Year
Speaker:
Chris Mount-Benites, Associate Superintendent Business Services
Comments:

This item serves to update the Board on the budget transfers that are needed in the building and construction funds.  The District’s Board Policy indicates that budgets are updated at the interim report periods. However, the VLS Audit Reports recommends (TC5, TC6) that the building funds be updated with the board more frequently.

Education Code 42600 allows for transfers to be made from the designated fund balance or the unappropriated fund balance to any expenditure classification or between expenditure classifications (major objects) at any time by written resolution of the board of education of any school district governed by a board of education. District staff has updated the budgets for Bond Fund 21.

In order to maintain proper accounting in object code accounts for various funds, budget revisions, resulting increases and/or decreases in appropriations for the 2017-18 fiscal year must be authorized by the Board through a resolution. 

This resolution is a result of project close-out for De-Anza $106,280, Greenwood Academy $455,582 and Montalvin $250,000.  Income of $22,510 was received after contract reconciliation (Valley View $16,825 & De Anza $5,685).    

For Fund 21 there is an increase of Fund Balance of $834,372.


Actions:
Motion
Ms. Kronenberg moved to Adopt Resolution No. 54-1718 Budget Revisions, Resulting Increases and/or Decreases in Appropriations for the 2017-18 Budget Year. Mr. Panas seconded. Ms. Block, Ms. Kronenberg, Mr. Panas, Mr. Phillips, and President Cuevas voted yes, with no abstentions and no absences. Motion carried 5-0-0-0. Passed with a motion by Madeline Kronenberg and a second by Tom Panas.
Vote:
Yes Liz Block.
Yes Valerie Cuevas.
Yes Madeline Kronenberg.
Yes Tom Panas.
Yes Mister Phillips.
Financial Impact:

Budget revision for Fund 21 – Bond Fund


Minutes:
Associate Superintendent Mount-Benites provided information regarding budget transfers.

Public Comment:
None

Board Comment:
Mr. Phillips stated that monies were put back into the Bond program from three schools that were completed under budget. The public should be aware of the good fortune. Ms. LeBlanc affirmed that funds were returned to budgets following reconciliation.
Attachments:
1. Resolution 54-1718
2. Resolution 54-1718 Budget Summary 010318
G.9. Pinole Valley High School New Campus Change Order Approval
Speaker:
Lisa LeBlanc, Associate Superintendent Facilities, M&O, Bond
Comments:

Pursuant to Board direction, all change orders that cause a contract’s cost to exceed ten percent (10%), or are of an individual value of $250,000 or more, will be considered for action separately from change orders not meeting these criteria.

The Pinole Valley High School New Campus project requires modifications to the hillside retaining wall to accommodate existing site conditions. The retaining walls are necessary to maintain fire access around the back of the campus. The additional cost is greater than $250,000. It would be futile to publically bid the work in question because of the tight time frames to complete this work without affecting the operations of the District, and that the public is best served by having this work completed by the contractor on the project. The additional cost is within the Board approved Project budget.





Company



Original Contract Amount

Previously Ratified CO's

CO's Pending
Approval

Change
Percent

Total CO's

Total CO
% of
Original Contract

Adjusted New Contract

Change Order Number

Lathrop Construction Associates, Inc.

$129,894,002

$619,791

$293,030

0.23%

$912,821

0.70%

$130,806,823

26




Actions:
Motion
Ms. Kronenberg moved approval the PVHS New Campus Change Order Approval. Mr. Panas seconded. Ms. Kronenberg, Mr. Panas, and President Cuevas voted yes, Mr. Phillips voted no, with no abstentions and no absences. Motion carried 4-1-0-0. Passed with a motion by Madeline Kronenberg and a second by Tom Panas. Passed with a motion by Madeline Kronenberg and a second by Tom Panas.
Vote:
Yes Liz Block.
Yes Valerie Cuevas.
Yes Madeline Kronenberg.
Yes Tom Panas.
No Mister Phillips.
Financial Impact:

 $293,030.00 Funded from Bond Fund. (21-9748-6211-362-0000-8500-400130-0-0000)

Minutes:
Engineering Officer Luis Freese detailed this item and explained the funds used to extend and modify a retaining wall.

Public Comment:
None

Board Comment:
Ms. Block remarked about the high costs of removal of dirt for hillsides. She stated consideration in the future should be done minimally to avoid costs. Mr. Phillips questioned the additional costs and asked whether bidding out could avoid the change order. Mr. Freese noted outside bids would have created delays and difficulty for the contractor.
G.10. Korematsu Middle School Drain Pipe Change Order Approval
Speaker:
Lisa LeBlanc, Associate Superintendent Facilities, M&O, Bond
Comments:

Pursuant to Board direction, all change orders that cause a contract’s cost to exceed ten percent (10%), or are of an individual value of $250,000 or more, will be considered for action separately from change orders not meeting these criteria.

The Korematsu Middle School Drain Pipe project required unforeseen modifications to piping installation, removal and disposal of unsuitable soils and relocation of irrigation piping to accommodate fence post footing at the pedestrian ramp. The additional cost will increase the total contract’s change order percentage to exceed ten percent. It would be futile to publically bid the work in question because of the tight time frames to complete this work without affecting the operations of the District, and that the public is best served by having this work completed by the contractor on the project. The additional cost is within the Board approved Project budget.

 

 

 

 

Company

 

 

Original Contract Amount

Previously Ratified CO's

CO's Pending
Approval

Change
Percent

Total CO's

Total CO
% of
Original Contract

Adjusted New Contract

Change Order Number

J3C Construction

$8,650.00

$0.00

$1,827.59

21.13%

$1,827.59

21.13%

$10,477.59

1

 


Actions:
Motion
Ms. Kronenberg moved approval of the Korematsu Middle School Drain Pipe Change Order Approval. Mr. Panas seconded. Ms. Block, Ms. Kronenberg, Mr. Panas, Mr. Phillips, and President Cuevas voted yes, with no abstentions and no absences. Motion carried 5-0-0-0. Passed with a motion by Madeline Kronenberg and a second by Tom Panas.
Vote:
Yes Liz Block.
Yes Valerie Cuevas.
Yes Madeline Kronenberg.
Yes Tom Panas.
Yes Mister Phillips.
Financial Impact:

  $1,827.59 Funded from Bond Fund. (21-9745-6219-214-0000-8500-400130-0-0000)

Minutes:
Engineering Officer Luis Freese explained the extra costs for drainage.

Public Comment:
None

Board Comment:
Mr. Phillips asked about work completion and timing of the change order. Mr. Freese responded with information for clarification.
H. UNFINISHED REQUESTS TO ADDRESS THE BOARD
Minutes:
None
I. COMMENTS FROM THE BOARD OF EDUCATION AND FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
Minutes:
Ms. Block congratulated President Cuevas’ leadership and commended the good first meeting.

Ms. Kronenberg congratulated President Cuevas on her first meeting. She noted the hard decisions made and looked to move forward in the New Year.

Mr. Panas stated this was an historic evening with the approval of the first design build contract and thanked staff for making this event come about.

Mr. Phillips welcomed everyone back. He also read a letter to Superintendent Duffy regarding K-12 athletics and specifically about the Hercules wrestling program.

President Cuevas stated that TK-Kindergarten registration would begin on January 10, 2018.
J. THE NEXT SCHEDULED BOARD OF EDUCATION MEETING
Quick Summary / Abstract:

Lovonya DeJean Middle School - January 17, 2018

Minutes:
Lovonya DeJean Middle School–January 17, 2018
K. ADJOURNMENT
Quick Summary / Abstract:

At 10:00 PM, any items remaining on the agenda that require immediate attention will be moved to this time.  All other items will be tabled to another or the following Board meeting in order to make fair and attentive decisions.  The meeting will adjourn at 10:30 PM.  The meeting may be extended by a majority vote of the Board of Education.

Minutes:
President Cuevas adjourned the meeting at 12:03 AM.
Disability Information:
Special Accommodations: Upon written request to the District, disability-related modifications or accommodations, including auxiliary aids or services, will be provided. Please contact the Superintendent’s Office at 510-231-1101 at least 48 hours in advance of meetings.

The resubmit was successful.